When a Change of Control Takes Away Your Severance: How C-Level Executives Can Fight Back

By Robert Adelson on 24 October 26   Executive Employment

CEO World Magazine logoThis article was published on October 18, 2026 in CEOWorld.

As a  CEO, C-level officer or other senior executive, you may have negotiated significant severance protection when you joined your company. If so, and you are terminated without cause, or resign for good reason, your executive contract may provide 12 months or more of salary, bonus, benefits, equity vesting and other protections.

But what if another provision in your contract says those severance rights disappear when your employer is acquired? That means you could spend years helping build the company, position it for acquisition and then devote enormous time and effort to completing the transaction—only to discover that the successful sale of the company eliminates the very severance protection you would need to transition to your new employment.

This is even worse than the usual “double trigger” I have discussed and opposed in two previous articles, the first of which was: Fighting the Double Trigger as Free Labor vs Slavery: How to Negotiate Your Own Change of Control Acceleration Terms. With a double trigger, change-of-control benefits typically depend upon both the completion of the acquisition and a second condition or trigger that you are terminated without cause by the successor entity within one year of the change of control. You may not like that second trigger, but at least there remains a route to receiving the benefits. A provision that simply extinguishes your severance when the company is acquired can leave you with no protection at all!

Considering that the buyer may combine divisions, eliminate overlapping CFO, COO and other c-level positions, move headquarters, or substantially change your responsibilities and reporting relationships, that is a serious contractual risk.  It is a risk that should be addressed when you negotiate your executive employment agreement—not after an acquisition is already underway.

The Business Argument to Use Against the Company Removing Your Severance at Change of Control

There is a powerful business argument against these severance forfeiture provisions, and it is more convincing to the employer than simply arguing that the clause is unfair.

It creates the wrong incentive.

Suppose your employer is preparing for sale, and you know that once the acquisition closes, your severance will disappear. What are you likely to start thinking about?

Instead of concentrating on completing the transaction, you may try to find another job before the deal closes.

The company would not want that.

An acquisition is often one of the most demanding periods in the life of a company. It needs its executives fully engaged in the endeavor: preparing due-diligence materials, meeting potential buyers, working with investment bankers and lawyers, reassuring employees and customers and continuing to run the business.

Yet the severance-forfeiture provision creates a disincentive that effectively tells the executive: If you help us successfully complete this transaction, you will lose your job protection. Thus the contract places the executive’s interests and the company’s interests in conflict, causing the executive to try to jump ship before the acquisition happens.

Examples from Sports Where a Coach Focused on His Next Position, Harmed His Current Team

We can see the danger of that kind of divided incentive well beyond the corporate world. Here are two examples from the world of sports.

Bill Parcells: From New England Patriots to New York Jets (1997)

Coach Bill Parcell had already led the New York Giants to two Super Bowl championships before taking over a struggling New England Patriots franchise in 1993. The Patriots had just finished 2–14. Four seasons later, Parcells had led them all the way to Super Bowl XXXI.

Yet Parcells had also become increasingly unhappy with restrictions on his authority under Patriots ownership, particularly over personnel decisions.

The situation culminated during the Patriots’ remarkable 1996 season. New England reached the Super Bowl but lost to Green Bay 35–21 on January 26, 1997. Five days later, Parcells resigned. He then moved on to coach the New York Jets.

I remember watching that Super Bowl and believing that Parcells was not at his best. There appeared to me to be coaching decisions uncharacteristic of one of the greatest coaches of his era. Desmond Howard was the top kickoff return special teams player in the NFL yet the Pats did not avoid him on kickoffs and Howard returned one kickoff 99 yards for a touchdown. I do not suggest that anyone can prove that Parcell’s impending departure caused the Patriots’ defeat. But when a highly valuable individual like a Coach or CEO knows his relationship with his current organization is coming to an end and his next opportunity beckons, the organization has created the risk of divided attention.

The Patriots needed Parcells thinking about nothing but winning the Super Bowl. Yet Parcells had every reason to be thinking about where he would be coaching next.  After the defeat, Parsells did not return with his team, opting instead to travel straight to New York to confer on his next job.

A company preparing for acquisition should not create this kind of incentive for its key executives.

Dusty May: From Florida Atlantic to University of Michigan (2024)

A more recent example comes from college basketball.

Dusty May transformed Florida Atlantic University basketball. In 2023, he took FAU on an extraordinary run to the Final Four, turning a relatively obscure basketball program into a national contender.

The following season, expectations were understandably high. FAU returned to the NCAA Tournament and faced Northwestern—my law school alma mater—in the first round on March 22, 2024.  Although FAU Owls was heavily favored over the lower rated Wildcats, Northwestern won 77–65 in overtime. FAU committed 21 turnovers and made only five of 27 three-point attempts.

Although unlike Parsells, May did return on the team plane with his players, two days after the FAU defeat, the University of Michigan announced that May would become its new head basketball coach. The extensive long-term contract between the University and Coach May appeared to me to be the product of extensive negotiations.

Again, I cannot know what was going through May’s mind as FAU prepared for its NCCA Tournament run including the opening game vs Northwestern, it appears to me that May may not have been totally focused on his current team, and FAU’s loss does not establish otherwise. But the timing illustrates the same problem. A coach preparing for the NCAA Tournament while simultaneously facing the possibility of a major career move has competing interests demanding his attention. Discussions with agents, employers, family and others concerning the next job do not occur in a vacuum.

Whether or not distraction affected either Parcells or May, employers should understand the broader lesson: Do not structure an executive’s incentives so that protecting his or her own career requires focusing on the next job while you most need that executive focused on the current one.

executive losing his severance

Ways for You, as Executive, to Negotiate Away the Severance Forfeiture Clause

If you find yourself faced with a Severance Forfeiture provision, I would suggest making this argument directly to the employer:

“You want me completely focused on maximizing the value of this company and completing a successful transaction. I too want to do that. But my contract should not give me a financial incentive to move to another job before the deal closes.”

That turns the negotiation from a demand for your benefit alone into an argument about successful deal execution to benefit both sides.

Here are the terms that you should seek:

  • Require the successor to assume your agreement, including its severance obligations.
    Your contract can provide that any successor must expressly assume the company’s obligations to you. Failure to obtain that assumption constitutes a breach or gives you the right to terminate for Good Reason and receive your severance.
  • Preserve severance during a post-closing protection period.
    You should negotiate for your normal severance rights to continue for 12 months following the acquisition. If the buyer terminates you without cause during that period, you receive your severance.  This should be supplemented with a Good Reason provision so that the successor company may not be able to hollow out your position while leaving you with the unattractive choice of accepting the diminished role or resigning with nothing.
  • Negotiate retention separately.
    The employer may respond that the buyer needs assurance that management will remain after closing. That may be entirely legitimate. But eliminating your existing severance protection is not the appropriate way to achieve it.  Instead, you should negotiate a retention agreement with the buyer. The buyer can offer a retention bonus, additional equity or other compensation in return for your commitment to remain. But your existing severance should not become the consideration for that new obligation.

Preparing Yourself as the Executive; Negotiate Away Severance Forfeiture Before It Costs You

If you find language in your offer letter, employment agreement or change-of-control terms, providing that your severance rights disappear upon a merger, acquisition or other change of control, do not treat it as boilerplate. Negotiate it! At a minimum, you should seek to preserve your existing severance rights after the transaction, require the successor company to assume those obligations and maintain strong Good Reason protection if your role, authority, compensation or reporting relationship is materially diminished.

The rationale behind the negotiation is that a company preparing for sale should want its senior executives focused on maximizing value and helping get the transaction successfully across the finish line. It should not create an incentive for them to jump ship before closing.

Severance-forfeiture provisions can often be negotiated, but they need to be identified before the transaction is underway and before your leverage has diminished. It is best to get help from an experienced executive severance attorney. Counsel who regularly represents C-level executives can help identify the risk and negotiate protections that would keep your interests aligned with the company’s rather than forcing you to choose between protecting your career and helping complete the deal.

********

Photo by Vitaly Gariev on Unsplash

Share